The Basic Concepts Of Locus Standi In Civil Suits Vis- A -Vis The Doctrine Of Legitimate Expectation

The concept of Locus standi denotes the legal capacity to institute, initiate or commence an action in a competent court of law or tribunal without any inhibition, obstruction or hindrance from any person or body. Locus standi is the right of appearance in a court of law to litigate or ventilate an issue. The question whether a plaintiff has locus standi to bring an action in the first place does not depend on the success or the merit of the case, but on whether the plaintiff has sufficient interest or legal right in the subject matter of the dispute to entitle him to institute the action.

 

The legal concept of locus standi is predicated on the assumption that no court is obliged to provide a remedy for a claim in which the applicant has a remote, hypothetical or no interest.  A party instituting an action in court must have a locus standi. He must have the legal capacity to invoke the judicial power entrenched in Section 6(6) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended). He must show that he has a stake in the subject matter, and must be able to establish that he suffered from defendant’s act or conduct. In the case of B.B. APUGU & SONS LTD V. O.H.M.B. (2016)13 NWLR (PT. 1529) 206 AT 269-270 PARAS G-A, the court held that a plaintiff has locus standi if he can show that there is a nexus between his action and the defendant’s conduct.

 

The right of a person to institute an action in court is derivable from the Constitution, the statutes, customary law or voluntary arrangement in an organization. Locus standi cannot be determined by foreign cases. In the case of DIAMOND PET. INT’L LTD V. GOV. C.B.N. (2015) 14 NWLRb (PT. 1478) 179 AT 199 PARA A, the court held that foreign cases are not helpful on the issue of locus standi in Nigeria bearing in mind the giant leap or strides in the development of jurisprudence in such foreign jurisdictions with their peculiarities”.

 

Locus standi is one of the thresholds of instituting a suit. It is one of the fulcrums for instituting an action in the Nigerian courts. Locus standi affects the jurisdiction of the court, and therefore, can be raised at any time in the proceedings or on appeal. If a plaintiff does not have locus standi to institute an action, the court would have no jurisdiction to entertain the suit. In the case of A.G. FED V. A.G. LAGOS STATE (2017) 8 NWLR (PT 1566) 20 AT 55 PARA D, the Supreme Court held that the question whether a plaintiff has locus standi to bring an action in the first place raises an issue of jurisdiction. See also the case of LIBA V. KOKO (2017) 11 NWLR (PT. 1576) 335 AT 355-356) PARAS H-C, where the court held that when a plaintiff has been found not to have the standing to sue, the question whether other issues in the case had been properly decided or not does not arise. This is because the trial court had no jurisdiction to entertain the claim. The correct position of the law therefore is that where a plaintiff is held to lack the locus standi to maintain his action, the finding goes to the jurisdiction of the court and denies its jurisdiction to determine the action”.

 

The rule on locus standi was developed to protect the courts from being used as a playground by professional litigants, busy bodies, and meddlesome interlopers who have no real interest in the subject matter of the litigation. Therefore, a person has locus standi to sue if he is able to show to the satisfaction of the court that his civil rights and obligations have been or are in danger of being infringed by another person. The law is trite that before a person can institute an action in court, he must ensure that there is a dispute between the parties, and the dispute is justiciable. See the case of JUKOK INT’L LTD V. DIAMOND BANK PLC (2016) 6 NWLR (PT 1507) 55 AT 94 PARA A, where the court held that the tests for determining locus standi are; the action must be justiciable and there must be a dispute between the parties. However, in A.G. FED V. A.G. LAGOS STATE (SUPRA) 40 PARAS E-H, the Supreme court held that when a party’s locus standi is in issue, the question is whether the person whose standing is in issue is a proper party to request an adjudication of a particular issue and not whether the issue itself is justiciable.

 

Furthermore, to have a locus standi to institute an action, the statement of claim must disclose the plaintiff’s sufficient legal interest and show how such interest arose in the subject matter of the action. Therefore, in order to determine whether a plaintiff has locus standi, the court is required to look at the writ of summons and statement of claim.

 

Locus Standi and the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation

 

The doctrine of legitimate expectation applies in determining locus standi. By the doctrine of legitimate expectation, the aggrieved person must establish that he lost the advantage he used to enjoy in the past on the promise or permission of the adversary which he had legitimately expected to continue to enjoy but was abruptly taken away by the adversary without notice to him. In such a case, the doctrine of legitimate expectation applies to give the plaintiff the locus standi to sue for the vindication of the right at which the adversary may explain the reasons for the withdrawal of the advantage. The condition on which the doctrine would apply must arise from an express promise or from the existence of a regular practice which the plaintiff can reasonably expect to continue.

 

There is a close connection between Locus standi and Cause of action. Both of them move together or merge like Siamese twins. In other words, locus standi and cause of action must merge or collapse into each other for the purposes of ascertaining whether there is a justiciable action before the court. When a court comes to conclusion that the plaintiff has no locus standi to institute an action in court, the proper order the court can make is to strike out the action. See the case of ADELEKE V. C.B.N. (2017) 11 NWLR (PT. 1575) 1 AT 30 PARA C, where the court held that only and proper order to make if the court comes to a conclusion that the plaintiff lacks locus standi is to strike out the suit.

 

-Miracle Akusobi, Esq.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *