Alternative Dispute Resolution: Revisiting The Approaches For Conflict Settlement In Nigeria

Introduction 

Abraham Lincoln is reputed to have said: “Discourage Litigation, persuade your neighbors to compromise whenever you can. Point out to them how the normal winner is often the loser – in fees, expenses, and waste of time. As a peacemaker, the lawyer has a superior opportunity of being a good man. There will still be business enough.”1

The above quote largely captures the predominant drawbacks inherent in litigation and it is arguable that a shift from litigation will play a major role in enhancing the attainment of peace and justice in any society including Nigeria.

Nigeria as a country is largely conflict ridden. Beginning from militancy in the oil-rich Niger Delta Region of the Country to the religious conflicts in the North and more recently the Farmers and herders clash in the middle belt region. These conflicts are most times not unconnected to disputants’ frustrations of not getting justice in good time should they approach the Court. When they approach the Courts, the overburdened Court dockets lead to prolonged litigations with no justice in sight. These experiences have resulted in the lack of confidence in the judicial system and can be explained as to why disputants take matters into their hands.

Following the above, many have anchored the advocacy of adopting other means of dispute resolution as against litigation. These clamors have birthed various Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) initiatives including the Multi-Door Courthouse (MDCH) system which is currently operating in a number of states in Nigeria with the earliest established in 2002 in Lagos State. 

Notwithstanding the move towards substantially adopting ADR as a preferred means of dispute resolution in Nigeria, the majority of the populace remain skeptical of its effectiveness. Consequently, litigation still holds sway as the first option for most disputants in Nigeria with people beginning their dispute journey with the phrase; “let’s go to Court!”

Against this backdrop, this paper aims at emphasizing the gains of and continuing need for a paradigm shift from litigation. The drawbacks of the Court system in Nigeria are therefore addressed in clear statistical terms and the achievements of the ADR initiatives within the short period of its adoption will be highlighted. 

The Problem of Delayed Justice Administration in the Nigerian Judicial System 

Mankind has aspired for justice from time immemorial and the unnecessary and frequent delays in judicial proceedings have adverse effects on the administration of justice. Sadly, getting justice from the average Nigerian Court can be hindered by a plethora of inadequacies ranging from time consumption arising from a series of adjournments, misplaced case files owing to improper document/file management, administrative decisions such as frequent transfer of judges and cases which sometimes necessitate trial de novo, insufficient staffing, inadequate infrastructure, and technological innovations, to mention but a few. These inadequacies have overtime resulted in the loss of confidence in the judicial system by the masses. 

Delay in final disposition of cases is a major challenge. While cases last up to five years at the trial court, the ones on appeal to the Supreme Court can last from ten to fifteen years2 , with exception to Election Petitions3 . Cases sometimes get to the Supreme Court, only to be redirected to the court of first instance for a trial de novo. 

The case of Ariori v Elemo4 perfectly illustrates this point. The case, a land dispute lasted fifteen years at the trial court. By the time it was ripe for hearing at the Supreme Court, the court held that the inordinate delay in the trial court had occasioned a miscarriage of justice. It ordered a trial de novo. By that time, the case was twenty years old.5 In Rossek & Ors v. ACB Ltd & Ors,6 an order of retrial was made after fifteen years of litigation spanning the trial and appellate courts. Also, in Ogbuyinya v. Okudo,7 the case took approximately thirty-two years before it was resolved at the Supreme Court8 . 

In the face of these inadequacies associated with the regular court system, moves have been made towards developing a more efficient means of justice delivery in Nigeria.

ADR Initiatives to the Rescue 

Recognizing a problem and creating solutions for the problem are two different things. It was in the spirit of proposing a solution to the slow dispensation of justice that Mr. Kehinde Aina9 facilitated the establishment of the Lagos State Multi-Door Courthouse in 2002. The Multi-Door Courthouses (MDCH) of different States have turned out to be major ADR centers in the Country at the forefront of changing the landscape of justice delivery. 

One among the major impacts of the Multi-Door Courthouse is its efforts in decongesting the Courts’ docket on simple contractual issues and giving room and resources for cases whose subject matters cannot be resolved under the ADR structure10 . Thus, the Multi-Door Courthouse is a convenient dispute clearing house for our congested Courtrooms.

Benefits of the Multi-Door Courthouse System in Dispute Resolution

  1.   The Multi-Door Court provides the citizenry a faster means of dispute resolution and at a much cheaper rate compared to litigation. 
  2.   Unlike litigation where parties are usually compelled to engage the services of a private counsel because of technicalities, there is a little need to engage a private counsel in the MDCH process as there are no technicalities and parties can speak for themselves. 
  3.   The confidentiality of the process enables business entities to settle disputes privately and away from the public to mitigated losses and prevent scandals. 
  4.   The Courts are then focused on directing their resources towards addressing more complex cases. This allows for maximum concentration, prompt and efficient dispensation of justice.
  5.   The MDCH gives Parties alternative options in resolving their disputes such as using either Mediation, Conciliation, amongst others, unlike the mono door court system where Parties have just one option of litigation. 
  6. At the MDCH, cases are matched with the appropriate door having an expert in the subject area to facilitate the dispute resolution process, unlike litigation where a judge is expected to entertain matters on all subject areas notwithstanding their area of competence. 
  7. Where disputes are settled using the ADR process, prior relationships are maintained, and cases are resolved on a win-win basis. This promotes peaceful coexistence in the society and minimizes bitterness among prior disputants. This cannot be said about litigation as underscored by the popular saying that “no two people go to court and return as friends.” 
  8.   Finally, the greatest benefit is the fact that the Multi-Door Court helps in bringing the much-needed peace in society. This method of dispute resolution which is party-driven tends to generate less tension and less acrimony between the parties thereby encouraging and sustaining peace in the society. 

Notwithstanding the many advantages of ADR, it has its own limitations as outlined below:

  1.   The ADR process other than Arbitration is largely informal and depends on the agreement of parties13. Where parties fail to settle, they resort back to Court for the determination of their rights. The MDCH has no power to make a binding order on the parties who fail to reach a settlement. This is unlike litigation where the decision of the Court is independent of the opinion of parties. 
  2.   Other than Arbitration proceedings, the outcome of other MDCH options14 may need to be adopted in Court as consent judgment to be enforceable, except otherwise stated. Thus, where Mediation is adopted in resolving a dispute, the agreement between parties are binding contracts and can only be enforceable when adopted as a consent judgment in Court. The inability to automatically enforce the MDCH decision after it is made is a clog on the wheel of the ADR process which in turn drags the cumbersome Court procedure into the arena of ADR. 
  3.     The MDCH lacks the powers to make injunctive orders to forestall any threat to the subject matter in contention of a dispute. In litigation, the Court can grant an injunction to restrain a party from interfering with the subject matter of the suit before the determination of the matter. The MDCH has no such powers and this may lead to the destruction of the subject matter before the conclusion of the ADR proceedings.
  4.   Where a party is dissatisfied, the decisions of the MDCH process lack direct appellate remedies. This is a grave disadvantage that may lead people to undermine the process and consider it as a waste of time.

Conclusion and Recommendations 

Not all cases can be referred to the MDCH for resolution. Criminal case15 , matters needing constitutional interpretation and fundamental rights enforcement cases need the direct intervention of the Courts based on their peculiarities. It is however my opinion that matters of fundamental rights enforcement can be addressed under the ADR process. A person whose fundamental rights have been infringed upon may demand reliefs such as public apology, damages in monetary compensation, or restitution to status quo ante. These relieves can be negotiated and granted under the ADR process and matters of this nature should be permitted to enjoy the timely dispensation that accompanies the ADR process. 

Apart from the MDCHs, there are other States and private institutions operating as ADR Centers with seasoned professionals facilitating dispute resolution16. The success of these ADR platforms shows the need to evolve more avenues of dispute resolution other than litigation. There is a need for a mental re-orientation of the mind of the common Nigerian who thinks that approaching the Court for dispute resolution is the only way to resolve a dispute, notwithstanding the challenges in the way of justice. An average Nigerian Lawyer also thinks that advising clients to opt for ADR would mean that professional fees will not be earned, which is often not so.

The paradigms are however changing and doing so very rapidly. ADR mechanisms have clearly come to stay and need to be wholly embraced in our society for better justice delivery and conflict resolution in Nigeria. It is pertinent to applaud the approach adopted by the Lagos State Judiciary where all instituted cases are first screened to identify if they are capable of being resolved through the ADR track. Such cases are automatically then transferred to the MDCH for resolution and the outcome adopted as a consent judgment in Court. This practice should be encouraged in all States as this will increase the confidence of disputants in the MDCH process.

There is also the need to strengthen the legal framework in Nigeria to embrace the practice of out of court settlement of disputes. This will mitigate the untold effects of delay in the administration of justice and encourage the peaceful coexistence of members of the society. It will also alleviate the unimaginable consequences of constant communal crises, violent attacks, and political unrest currently on the rise in Nigeria.

Bibliography 

Akeredolu, A. (2013) ‘A Comparative Appraisal of the Practice and Procedure of Court Connected Alternative Dispute Resolution in Nigeria, United States Of America And United Kingdom’. Thesis (Ph.D.), University of Ibadan, Nigeria.

Akper, P. “Promoting the Use of ADR Processes in Court. What is ADR and Practical Exercises on Negotiation and Mediation.” (A paper delivered at the Conference of All Nigeria Judges of the lower courts organised by the National Judicial Institute. Lagos, 2002, MIJ Publishers, p.145

Amadi, J. (2009) Enhancing Access to Justice in Nigeria with Judicial Case Management Norm in Common Countries, (Nigeria: Centre for African Law and Development (CALD), Monograph Series) 74 accessible via https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228208569_Enhancing_Access_to_Justice_in_Nigeria _with_Judicial_Case_Management_An_Evolving_Norm_in_Common_Law_Countries/citation/do wnload 

Odibo, M., “Access to Justice Through Court Annexed Alternative Dispute Resolution Programmes: A Critical Assessment of the Multi-Door Courthouse System in Nigeria”, Paper presented to the Society of Legal Scholars, Oxford, 8 September 2016, p. 9

Onyema E. and Odibo M., How alternative dispute resolution made a comeback in Nigeria’s courts [Online], accessed via https://www.africaresearchinstitute.org/newsite/publications/counterpoints/alternative-disputeresolution-made-comeback-nigerias-courts/ (accessed on 10th December 2019)

Partridge, M. V. B., (2009). Alternative Dispute Resolution – An Essential Competency for Lawyers. New York: Oxford University Press. P. 152.

References 

1Abraham Lincoln, former President of the United States, in Partridge, M. V. B., (2009). Alternative Dispute
Resolution – An Essential Competency for Lawyers. New York: Oxford University Press. P. 152.

2Amadi, J. (2009) Enhancing Access to Justice in Nigeria with Judicial Case Management Norm in Common Countries,
(Nigeria: Centre for African Law and Development (CALD), Monograph Series) 74 accessible via
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228208569_Enhancing_Access_to_Justice_in_Nigeria_with_Judicial_Case_
Management_An_Evolving_Norm_in_Common_Law_Countries/citation/download (Accessed on 10th December 2019)

3 Judgment must be delivered on Election Petitions within180 days of filing the Petition and within 60 days if on appeal.
4
(1981) SC 1.

5See also, the cases of Olaleye v. NNPC cited in Akper, P. “Promoting the Use of ADR Processes in Court. What is ADR
and Practical Exercises on Negotiation and Mediation.” (A paper delivered at the Conference of All Nigeria Judges of the
lower courts organised by the National Judicial Institute. Lagos, 2002, MIJ Publishers, p. 145; and Eperokun and Ors v.
University of Lagos, (1986) NWLR p. 152.

6(1993) 8 NWLR (Pt. 312) 382
7
(1990) 4 NWLR (Pt. 146) 551
8 Akeredolu, A. (2013) ‘A Comparative Appraisal of the Practice and Procedure of Court Connected Alternative Dispute
Resolution in Nigeria, United States Of America And United Kingdom’. Thesis (PhD), University of Ibadan, Nigeria.

9Author, speaker, founder of the Lagos Multi-Door Courthouse, Executive Director of Negotiation and Conflict
Management Group (NCMG), and nationally recognised ADR expert and Senior Partner of Aina Blankson LP; the
foremost private ADR Law firm in Africa.

10Such cases needing constitutional interpretation, Criminal proceedings, Matrimonial Causes (divorce proceedings),
Election Petition, Fundamental Rights Enforcement, amongst others.

13The Arbitration proceeding is a formal and binding process once parties decide to submit to it and a judicial award is
enforceable at anu Court of Law.
14 Such as Mediation, Negotiation, Conciliation, etc.

14Offences are committed against the State and offenders cannot settle with the victims as they are prosecuted by the
States. The only remedies available to victims here may be a refund of their stolen properties where they were still in
the possession of the offenders at the time of their arrest. There is also the concept of a plea bargain where offenders
plead guilty of a lesser offence for the prosecutor to dismiss other grievous charges and where the offender negotiates
for a more lenient sentence.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *